CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule: $90 Billion in Medicare Fraud Checks and What Your Practice Must Fix Before January 19, 2027
CMS issued the CRUSH proposed rule on November 16, aiming for nearly $90 billion in savings over 10 years. Comments are due January 19, 2027.

CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule: $90 Billion in Medicare Fraud Checks and What Your Practice Must Fix Before January 19, 2027
The CMS CRUSH proposed rule landed November 16, and it is the biggest Medicare integrity move of the year. CMS says the rule, called the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over 10 years. It tightens enrollment, forces Medicare Advantage plans to report fraud, and revives audits of Medicare Advantage plans that CMS says will recover about $9 billion per payment year. Public comments are due January 19, 2027, and the rule is set for Federal Register publication on November 19, 2026.
The same day, CMS released its fiscal year 2026 improper payment estimates: about $112.9 billion across 6 programs, up from $96.1 billion in fiscal year 2025. That number is not a fraud total. Most improper payments happen because a reviewer could not tell if a payment was proper, usually over missing or thin documentation. The two announcements together tell one story: CMS is moving from catching bad billing after the money is gone to blocking it at the front door. Your charts, your enrollment file, and your documentation are now the front line.
Table of contents
- What the CRUSH rule does
- The $112.9 billion improper payment number
- What changes for your practice
- What the 7.32% Medicare error rate means for your revenue
- What to do before January 19, 2027
- How CRUSH differs from the rules we already covered
- Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
- CMS issued the CRUSH proposed rule (CMS-6098-P) on November 16, 2026, aiming for nearly $90 billion in savings over 10 years. Comments are due January 19, 2027.
- About 150,000 providers who bill Medicare Advantage plans would have to enroll in Original Medicare first, with a projected start date of January 1, 2030.
- Every Medicare enrollment change would have a 30-day reporting deadline, down from up to 90 days for non-critical changes today.
- Fiscal year 2026 improper payments hit $112.9 billion, up from $96.1 billion, with Medicaid the largest piece at $46.84 billion.
- RADV audits of Medicare Advantage plans would recover about $9 billion per payment year, per CMS, and findings would be extrapolated across a whole contract.
What the CRUSH rule does
CRUSH covers Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP, and the Health Insurance Marketplace. It is a proposal, not a final rule, and nothing in it takes effect now. But the direction is clear. Here are the parts that touch a practice, in plain terms.
Enrollment gets tighter. Every provider and supplier would have to report any change to Medicare enrollment information within 30 calendar days. Today, critical changes get 30 days but other changes get up to 90. CMS also gains a new ground to deny or revoke Medicare enrollment when an owner or managing employee's identity cannot be confirmed, or when CMS decides an owner poses an undue risk of fraud.
Medicare Advantage providers face a new enrollment step. About 150,000 providers who bill Medicare Advantage plans would have to enroll in Original Medicare first, so CMS can screen them up front with identity checks, license checks, a site visit, and a fingerprint background check. The projected start date is January 1, 2030. If you see MA patients and never enrolled in Original Medicare, this is the provision to watch. The CMS fact sheet lays out the timeline, and HFMA covered the enrollment piece on November 17.
Fraud reporting becomes mandatory for plans. Medicare Advantage and Part D plans would have to report suspected or substantiated fraud to CMS. Today reporting is voluntary. Only 46% of MA and Part D plan contracts voluntarily reported fraud referrals in 2025, and only 19% reported any payment suspensions over a credible fraud allegation. That gap is why CRUSH makes it mandatory.
Medicare Advantage audits come back bigger. RADV audits of MA plans get revived and expanded. CMS drops the fee-for-service adjuster, sets its own sampling method, and extrapolates audit findings across a whole contract starting with payment year 2018. CMS estimates this collects about $9 billion per payment year in MA overpayments. Under current audit rules CMS expects to collect only $439.1 million over the same 10 years, so the proposal is about 205 times larger. RADV audits the plan, not your practice, but the chart requests land on your desk. Diagnosis documentation matters more when the plan's whole contract is on the line.
Medicaid gets a 60-day clock. Medicaid fee-for-service providers would have to self-report and return overpayments within 60 days, matching the rule already in place for Medicare. States could also suspend Medicaid payments based on a credible fraud finding made by CMS or another federal agency. Today, 75% of credible fraud allegations in 2025 did not result in payment suspensions because states used a good-cause exception.
Supplier marketing gets new limits. DMEPOS suppliers would have to disclose marketing, fulfillment, wholesale, and device-manufacturing relationships. The ban on unsolicited contact with beneficiaries expands from phone calls only to texts, social media messages, email without an opt-out, and door-to-door visits. This matters most to practices that refer patients to DME suppliers.
The rule costs $378.5 million to run over 10 years, against nearly $90 billion in savings, per CMS. Fierce Healthcare and Becker's Payer Issues both covered the announcement on November 16 and 17. The full proposed rule is up for public inspection at the Federal Register.
The $112.9 billion improper payment number
CMS released fiscal year 2026 improper payment estimates the same day as CRUSH, and the total rose to about $112.9 billion, up $16.8 billion, or about 17.4%, from $96.1 billion in fiscal year 2025. Becker's Hospital Review pulled the 9 numbers that matter. Here is the breakdown from the CMS fact sheet.
Program | Improper payments | Rate |
|---|---|---|
Medicaid | $46.84 billion | 7.08% |
Original Medicare | $33.96 billion | 7.32% |
Medicare Advantage (Part C) | $19.97 billion | 5.74% |
Medicare Part D | $5.42 billion | 4.90% |
CHIP | $2.26 billion | 9.81% |
Marketplace (ACA) | $4.44 billion | 5.75% |
Medicaid is the largest dollar piece, and its rate rose from 6.12% in fiscal year 2025. 79.41% of the Medicaid total came from insufficient documentation. Original Medicare hit 7.32%, or $33.96 billion, up from 6.55% and $28.83 billion. That is the 10th straight year below the 10% compliance threshold, but the dollar total still rose $5.1 billion. CHIP had the steepest rate rise, from 7.05% to 9.81%, with 55.93% of it from insufficient documentation.
Read the number right. CMS says improper payments are not the same as fraud. Most of the $112.9 billion happened because a reviewer could not tell if a payment was proper, usually because the documentation was missing or too thin. That is a paperwork problem, and it is the one part of this story your practice controls directly. Clean notes and complete charts are now the cheapest protection you have.
One more number from the CMS release: Medicare program integrity savings rose 59%, from $26.3 billion in fiscal year 2024 to a record $41.9 billion in fiscal year 2025, with a return of $22.30 for every $1 invested, up from $14.60. CMS is spending more on enforcement, and it is getting more back.
What changes for your practice
CRUSH is a proposal, so nothing changes tomorrow. But the direction sets your next 3 moves.
First, your enrollment file becomes a 30-day clock. If the rule is finalized as proposed, every change to your Medicare enrollment information gets 30 calendar days, not 90. A new practice location, a new owner, a changed managing employee, a new bank account: all of it on a 30-day clock. Start keeping enrollment changes on the same list as your credentialing dates, with a due date next to each one. Our Medicare enrollment revocation guide covers the separate final rule that already added retroactive clawbacks, and it is worth reading next to CRUSH so the two rules do not blur together.
Second, check whether you bill Medicare Advantage without Original Medicare enrollment. About 150,000 providers do, and CRUSH would make them enroll in Original Medicare first, with screening up front. The start date is January 1, 2030, which sounds far away, but enrollment, site visits, and fingerprint checks take months. If that is you, put it on the 2027 list, not the 2029 list.
Third, treat documentation as audit defense. RADV audits will pull charts from MA plans, and the findings get extrapolated across the whole contract. A plan that gets hit comes back to its providers with chart requests. Diagnosis codes need the note to back them up. The KFF analysis of Medicare Advantage coding intensity puts the stakes in context: MedPAC found Medicare pays MA plans $76 billion more in 2026 than traditional Medicare would spend for the same people, about 14% more, with $28 billion of that tied to coding intensity. That is why CMS is auditing coding so hard.
Medicaid providers get a fourth change: a 60-day clock to self-report and return overpayments, matching Medicare. If your billing team finds an overpayment, the clock starts when you identify it. Build the habit now: log it, report it, return it, and keep the record. The CMS home health and hospice moratorium article covers the separate enrollment freeze that is still running, and the Minnesota Medicaid denial article shows what happens when a state program loses federal funds.
What the 7.32% Medicare error rate means for your revenue
Original Medicare's fiscal year 2026 improper payment rate is 7.32%. That is a national average, not your practice's rate, but it puts a dollar figure on the pool of payments CMS flags each year. Here is the math for a small practice.
A practice that collects $1,000,000 a year from Original Medicare has $73,200 sitting in the flagged pool: $1,000,000 times 0.0732. A 5-physician practice collecting $2,500,000 from Medicare has $183,000 in that pool. Most of that pool is documentation, not fraud. Medicaid tells the same story: 79.41% of its $46.84 billion came from insufficient documentation.
Flip it to the fix. If better notes and coding cut your own error rate from 7.32% to 3%, the protected revenue on $1,000,000 of Medicare collections is $43,200 a year: $73,200 minus $30,000. That is the return on a documentation habit. One more angle: CMS assumes an average overpayment of $1,258 per enrollee in its RADV audit samples. A practice whose MA plan panel is 2,000 patients represents $2,516,000 of plan-level audit exposure, which comes back as chart requests. The audit hits the plan. The paperwork hits you.
What to do before January 19, 2027
The comment deadline is January 19, 2027. That is your window to shape the rule, and your deadline to get your house in order.
If the 30-day clock worries you, say so in a comment. CMS reads them, and small-practice burden is a real argument. If the rule is finalized, the practices that adjust early will have the least to fix.
How CRUSH differs from the rules we already covered
Two recent MDRG stories cover different CMS actions, and CRUSH is neither of them. The Medicare enrollment revocation final rule, CMS-1844-F, is final and already adds retroactive clawbacks worth $82 million a year. The home health and hospice enrollment moratorium is a separate freeze, extended 6 more months. CRUSH is a new proposed rule, CMS-6098-P, issued November 16, 2026, and it is still open for comment. Do not mix them up. If a vendor or a payer cites CRUSH as if it were already in force, it is not.
Find the number that costs you the most
A free audit pulls your last 90 days of claims, names the KPI that leaks the most money, and puts a dollar figure on it. It takes 48 hours.
Frequently asked questions
CRUSH stands for Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare. It is a proposed rule, CMS-6098-P, issued November 16, 2026. CMS says it could save nearly $90 billion over 10 years by tightening enrollment, making fraud reporting mandatory for Medicare Advantage plans, and expanding RADV audits.
No. It is a proposal. Public comments are due January 19, 2027, and the rule is set for Federal Register publication on November 19, 2026. Nothing in it takes effect until CMS issues a final rule.
It is the fiscal year 2026 improper payment estimate across 6 programs, up from $96.1 billion in fiscal year 2025. Most of it comes from insufficient documentation, not fraud. Medicaid is the largest piece at $46.84 billion, and Original Medicare is $33.96 billion at a 7.32% rate.
It could, if you bill a Medicare Advantage plan without being enrolled in Original Medicare. About 150,000 providers are in that group. The proposed start date is January 1, 2030, with screening up front, including a site visit and fingerprint background check.
Every change to Medicare enrollment information would have to be reported within 30 calendar days. Today, critical changes get 30 days but other changes get up to 90 days. The proposal puts every change on the 30-day clock.
Check your enrollment file, confirm your Original Medicare enrollment status, audit 20 recent charts for diagnosis support, and set up a 60-day Medicaid overpayment return path. If the 30-day clock or the MA enrollment step would hurt your practice, file a comment on the Federal Register docket for CMS-6098-P.
Sources
- CMS press release, CRUSH proposed rule aims for nearly $90 billion in savings: http://www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/cms-crush-proposed-rule-aims-reap-nearly-90-billion-taxpayers-savings-targeting-fraud-across
- CMS fact sheet, CRUSH proposed rule CMS-6098-P: https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/comprehensive-regulations-uncover-suspicious-healthcare-crush-proposed-rule-cms-6098-p
- CMS fact sheet, fiscal year 2026 improper payments: https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/fiscal-year-2026-improper-payments
- HFMA, CMS CRUSH proposed rule would increase fraud oversight: https://www.hfma.org/legal-and-regulatory-compliance/cms-crush-proposed-rule/
- Fierce Healthcare, CMS proposes sweeping Medicare integrity rule to save $90B: https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/regulatory/cms-proposes-sweeping-medicare-integrity-rule-it-says-will-save-90b
- Becker's Payer Issues, CMS targets $90B in savings with sweeping new anti-fraud rule: https://www.beckerspayer.com/policy-updates/cms-targets-90b-in-savings-with-sweeping-new-anti-fraud-rule/
- Becker's Hospital Review, CMS flags $112B+ in improper payments: https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/cms-flags-112b-in-improper-payments-9-things-to-know/
- KFF, decoding Medicare Advantage coding intensity: https://www.kff.org/medicare/decoding-medicare-advantage-coding-intensity/
- Federal Register public inspection, CRUSH proposed rule CMS-6098-P: https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2026-23461.pdf
- HMP Global Learning Network, proposed CMS CRUSH rule targets fraud: https://www.hmpgloballearningnetwork.com/site/frmc/news/proposed-cms-crush-rule-targets-fraud-across-federal-health-programs
Protect your Medicare & fee schedule revenue.
Get a custom code-by-code reimbursement impact analysis for your practice. Measure your financial variance in 48 hours.
